Showing posts with label Questions. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Questions. Show all posts

Tuesday, September 2, 2014

Questions that sociologists ask


Q. What sorts of questions do sociologists ask?

A. E.g., …


– ABSTRACT –

What are the qualities of a thing?

What are the causes of a thing?

What are the functions of a thing?

What is the relation between X & Y?

How does (X) contribute to (Y) (e.g., X = surveillance, Y = social domination)?

How does (X) determine the way (Y) is done?

What are the causes of this behavior?

How is (X) formed?

How does (X) work? X = fundamentalism, absolutism, conversation, DMV lines, war, Flickr culture (or a culture captured on Flickr), Facebook culture, twitter culture, etc.

How does this interaction affect this fact?

How are things organized?

How do these people live?

How are people produced?

How do people produce other people?

How do people produce non-people (e.g., technology, environments)?

How do people play the game of life? Which rules do they follow? What do they think the rules are? Which strategies do they use? Which sacrifices do they make? Which calculations do they make?


– LESS ABSTRACT –

What is the relation of these people to the means of production? What are their relations to people that have the same relation to the means of production? What are their relations to people that do not have the same relation to the means of production?

What are these members doing?

How does living in the city change one’s worldview, or emotional state?

How does technological change, globalization, etc. affect inequality?

How do business practices affect public health?

How does this government use the legal concept “terrorist” in order to police their citizens and noncitizens?

How do people make sense of or give meaning to tragic or terrifying situations?

How do people surveil each other and themselves? E.g., are people not effectively “spying” on themselves, if you will, by constantly reporting on themselves via social networking sites?

How does (X) change the rhythms and durations of how people organize their everyday life? X = cell phones, smartphones, social networking sites, email, automobiles, etc.

How do scientists produce facts?

How do people make movements?

Are sovereignty, discipline, and control different shapes/qualities of societies (i.e., associations)? And if so, how is a quality produced? And how is this production generalized? That is, how does it spread? Are these productions technology/medium/mediator-specific? Who are the members of this society? And how do they produce it? And how are they produced by it?

What are the conditions of living of a people?

What are these people’s analyses of (X) (e.g., some thing, some situation, some phenomenon, etc.)?

Which things are difficult for these people to speak about? (E.g., because of fear of actual or imagined threats, such as rejection by peers or loved ones, or dismissal from work, etc.)

What are the political strategies of these people?

– What knowledges or beliefs are these strategies based upon?

– What are these people fighting for?

– Who do these speakers name as the enemy? And the allies?
– What are these political strategists (activists) doing in order to recruit and involve others? How do they attract and organize other people?

Monday, September 1, 2014

What is a sociological question



Q. What do sociologists do?

A. They ask and answer sociological questions OR they explore sociological interests.

Q #1. What is a sociological question?

A. It is a question about the social or a question that has the social as its topic, subject matter, or thematic content.

Q. What is the social?

A. It is not a certain type of material, thing, or entity, but rather it is the associations between materials, things, or entities of all different types (e.g., chemical, physical, psychological, legal, biological, architectural, etc.). In other words, it is symbiosis or interaction. E.g., Observe the relation between SARS and human beings. SARS is clearly an entity that biology explores, but it enters into the realm of sociology as soon as it affects the associations that humans are part of. What happens when you get SARS? You must be quarantined away from the life that you once lived, from your loved ones, from your friends, etc. It is as if SARS was giving orders to you and all of the other associates in your life: “Don’t see your family. Don’t see your friends. Don’t go where you want to go.” Of course, this is a simplification but the basic idea still remains – SARS, which belongs to the realm of biology, also belongs to the realm of sociology because it rearranges social life, i.e., the associations that humans form with each other.

Q #2. What is a sociological question?

A. It is a question about the phenomenon of association. E.g., “How are things associated?” “How does this association, symbiosis, or interaction work?” “How does SARS change the way that people interact?”

Q. What is an interaction?

A. It is an acting-together, a concert, an ensemble of things. It is that phenomenon in which things make each other act or perform some specific action – this includes phenomena in which things allow each other to act, not merely phenomenon in which things cause each other to act. Therefore, sociology is the study of action or work, of labor and division of labor. “How do things act together?” “Which entities and their actions made this person perform this action?”

Q. What is the range or domain of sociology, given the above definitions?

A. Any and all symbioses that humans can study. However, more conservative and anthropocentric versions of sociology tend to require that humans be one of the entities associated in the associations that they study, and most tend to require that humans be the focus – even to the point of neglecting all nonhuman entities involved in an interaction with humans. E.g., this latter type of sociology might study war but only focus on human bodies, their movements, their cognition, etc. while neglecting the landscape that they traverse in the uncountable technologies that they bring into play. War cannot happen without these technologies or these landscapes, but some sociologists behave as if it could.

Q. What is intersubjectivity?

A. An intersubjective interaction is one in which humans act directly upon other humans, perhaps with no more mediation than that of sunlight (to mediate visual interaction) and atmosphere (to mediate verbal interaction). E.g., fistfights, sex, face-to-face conversations, face-to-face dating, face-to-face… Etc.

Q. What is interobjectivity?

A. An interobjective interaction is one in which humans act indirectly upon other humans, in the sense that they act directly upon nonhumans (i.e., objects), which in their turn act directly or indirectly upon humans (i.e., subjects) at the other end of the interaction. I might go so far as to assume that most human interactions are interobjective, as opposed to intersubjective. A sort of common sense proof of this would be to think about all of the objects that you use and all of the people that made and delivered these objects, and then to ask “How many of these people have I ever even met?”

Q. Why do sociologists need to take into account interobjectivity?

A. In order to study associations (or societies) and how they work, one must take into account ALL of the participants. To exclude objects from studies would be to fail to be object-ive because practically every interaction involving humans is full of objects (and objectors) – in order to be objective, sociologists must be object-ful. Imagine if mechanics were to pick and choose which parts of your car they would pay attention to, regardless of whether or not they were part of the problem; they would have a hard time figuring out how the problem worked and how to rework it into a solution. Thus…

Q #3. What is a sociological question?

A. It is a question that explores how humans and nonhumans work together to form associations (or societies).

Question basics



Basic Pragmatic Scientific Questions –

1. Past-Oriented Observation – What happened? How did it work? [What was happening? How was it working?]
2. Present-Oriented Observation – What is happening? How does it work? [How is it working?]
3. Predictive or Future-Oriented Speculation – What will happen? How will it work? What is likely to happen? [What will be happening? How will it be working?]
4. Experimental Perspective – What if…? What would happen if…? How would things unfold if…?
5. Puzzlement Perspective – Why does it work this way instead of that (or some other) way? This is a way of probing the question “How does it work?” instead of taking for granted that it works a certain (i.e., this) way.

Common Theoretical Questions –

Does something exist? 
What kind of thing is it? 
What caused it to exist, or under what conditions can it exist, or why does it exist? 
What purpose does it serve? 
What are the consequences of its existence? 
What are its characteristic properties, its typical traits? 
What are its relations to other things of a similar sort, or of a different sort? 
How does it behave?
What happens if this happens? (A. If this happens, then that will happen.)
What does this phenomenon (i.e., thing, action) do?
What will this (change or alteration) do?
What are the consequences of this happening? What effects does it produce?
What is the case? What is true?
Just (i.e., exactly) how is this the case?

Common Practical Questions –

What ends should be sought? 
What means should be chosen to a given end? 
What things must one do to gain a certain objective, and in what order? 
Under these conditions, what is the right thing to do, or the better rather than the worse? 
Under what conditions would it be better to do this rather than that?
What should be the case? What should be true?
What should be done? How should this be handled?
What opportunities should be available?

Describing a Phenomenon –

Naming the phenomenon
– What is happening?
Naming the participants
– To what is it happening?
– To whom is it happening?
– What is doing it?
– Who is doing it?
Naming the space-time
– When is it happening?
– Where is it happening?
Naming the alternative possibilities
– Would it happen differently if… (X)?
– Could it happen still if… (X)?

Question Statuses –

– already answered questions
1. consensus has been met – Task: do a lit review
2. dissensus remains – Task: [do a lit review] + controversy analysis
– unanswered questions – Task: [do a proxy lit review] + perform an analysis

Correlational Studies – 

Even correlational studies are trying to figure out the question “How does it work?” I.e., If [X condition or factor] is present, then it works such that [Y condition or factor] has [Z] value. E.g., If a person [belongs to a high tradition church], then this person [is less likely to kill themselves].